Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Share This Post

Overview of Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Titanium additive manufacturing, also known as 3D printing of titanium, refers to various additive manufacturing techniques used to fabricate titanium components in a layer-by-layer manner directly from 3D model data. It allows for the creation of complex titanium parts with high geometrical freedom that are either impossible or very costly to manufacture by traditional methods.

Titanium is an ideal material for additive manufacturing due to its high strength-to-weight ratio, corrosion resistance, biocompatibility, and high-temperature performance. However, processing titanium using additive techniques also poses some unique challenges due to its chemical reactivity and anisotropic material properties.

Some key details about titanium additive manufacturing:

  • Commonly used 3D printing methods for titanium are selective laser melting (SLM), electron beam melting (EBM), and direct metal laser sintering (DMLS).
  • Titanium alloys like Ti-6Al-4V are most widely used but commercially pure titanium and other alloys can also be printed.
  • Allows fabrication of lightweight, complex parts like lattice structures and thin-walled geometries.
  • Produces near net-shape parts, reducing wastage and cost compared to subtractive methods.
  • Provides flexibility in design and consolidation of assemblies into one printed part.
  • Post-processing like hot isostatic pressing (HIP) and machining is often required to achieve desired finish and material properties.
  • Properties comparable or superior to wrought, cast, and forged titanium but anisotropy is a concern.
  • Application areas include aerospace, medical implants, automotive, and chemical plants.
  • Higher cost than traditional manufacturing but economical for small batch sizes and complex parts.

Types of Titanium Additive Manufacturing Processes

Process Description Characteristics
Selective Laser Melting (SLM) Uses a laser to selectively melt and fuse metallic powder particles layer by layer Most common and mature technology <br> Good accuracy and surface finish <br> Low porosity in printed parts
Electron Beam Melting (EBM) Uses an electron beam as heat source to melt the material Relatively fast build rates <br> Parts have higher porosity compared to SLM <br> Only conductive materials can be processed
Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS) Uses a laser to sinter powder particles and create finished parts High accuracy and detail resolution <br> Slightly porous parts requiring infiltration
Directed Energy Deposition (DED) Focuses thermal energy to fuse materials by melting as they are being deposited Primarily used for adding features and repairs rather than complete parts <br> Higher build rates but lower accuracy
titanium additive manufacturing

Applications of Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Industry Uses and Examples
Aerospace Aircraft and engine components like hydraulic manifolds, valves, housings, brackets
Medical Dental and orthopedic implants, surgical instruments
Automotive Lightweight parts like manifolds, turbocharger wheels
Chemical Corrosion-resistant fluid handling parts like pipes, valves, pumps
Defense Lightweight load-bearing components for vehicles and weapons
General engineering Low-volume custom parts across industries

Specifications for Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Parameter Typical Values
Layer thickness 20 – 100 μm
Minimum feature size ~100 μm
Surface roughness, Ra 10 – 25 μm, higher in overhangs
Build volume 50 x 50 x 50 mm to 500 x 500 x 500 mm
Precision ± 0.1% to ± 0.2% on dimensions
Porosity 0.5 – 1% for SLM, up to 5% for EBM
Microstructure Fine, columnar prior beta grains with alpha laths

Design Considerations for Titanium AM Parts

  • Optimize part orientation to reduce supports and avoid overhangs
  • Use self-supporting angles greater than 45° to avoid supports
  • Thin walls (≤ 1 mm) need higher laser intensities and scan speeds
  • Minimum hole diameter should be ≥ 1 mm
  • Internal channels should be ≥ 2 mm for powder removal
  • Avoid hollow enclosed volumes in part
  • Ensure sufficient wall thickness (2-4 mm) for load-bearing parts
  • Allow for post-processing like machining, drilling, polishing etc.

Standards for Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Standard Description
ASTM F3001 Standard specification for additive manufacturing titanium-6 aluminium-4 vanadium ELI (Extra Low Interstitial) with powder bed fusion
ASTM F2924 Standard specification for additive manufacturing titanium-6 aluminium-4 vanadium with powder bed fusion
ASTM F3184 Standard specification for additive manufacturing stainless steel via powder bed fusion
ISO/ASTM 52921 Standard terminology for additive manufacturing – Coordinate systems and test methodologies
ASME BPVC Section IX Boiler and pressure vessel code for additive manufacturing qualifications

Suppliers of Titanium Additive Manufacturing Systems

Supplier Printer Models Starting Price Range
EOS EOS M 100, EOS M 290, EOS M 400 $200,000 – $1,500,000
SLM Solutions SLM® 125, SLM® 280, SLM® 500, SLM® 800 $250,000 – $1,400,000
3D Systems ProX® DMP 200, ProX® DMP 300, ProX® DMP 320 $350,000 – $1,250,000
GE Additive Concept Laser M2, M2 Multilaser, M2 Dual Laser $400,000 – $1,200,000
Velo3D Sapphire, Sapphire XC $150,000 – $600,000

Prices vary based on build volume, laser power, and additional features. Additional costs include installation, training, materials, and post-processing.

Operation and Maintenance of Titanium Printers

  • Obtain and follow manufacturer’s operating manual and safety precautions
  • Clean optical system and mirrors to maintain laser power and beam quality
  • Perform calibrations for laser and scanning system periodically
  • Conduct test prints to verify part quality before starting production builds
  • Develop standard operating procedures (SOPs) for printing parameters
  • Store and handle titanium powder properly in an inert environment
  • Clean build chamber regularly to remove condensed material and prevent contamination
  • Perform preventative maintenance like greasing linear guides, tightening fasteners, replacing filters

Choosing a Titanium Additive Manufacturing Supplier/Service Bureau

Considerations Details
Experience and expertise Years of experience, trained operators, metal AM expertise
Printer models and specifications Assess build volume, accuracy, materials etc.
Quality certifications ISO 9001, ISO 13485, Nadcap accreditation
Materials availability Range of titanium alloys, particle sizes, customized alloys
Post-processing capabilities Debinding, HIP, machining, polishing, coating
Part testing and validation Mechanical testing, NDT, metallography
Design support Topology optimization, design for AM guidelines
Production capacity Batch sizes, lead times, scalability, redundant capacity
Cost Machine hourly rates, material prices, additional charges
Client references and reviews Feedback on service quality from existing clients
titanium additive manufacturing

Pros and Cons of Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Advantages Limitations
Complex, lightweight geometries possible Higher cost than traditional manufacturing for large volumes
Consolidated assemblies and reduced part count Lower dimensional accuracy and surface finish than machining
Shorter lead times for low volume batches Post-processing often required to achieve desired properties
Reduced material waste Anisotropic material properties and residual stresses
Flexibility in design iterations Size limitations based on printer build volume
Just-in-time manufacturing Powder removal difficulties for complex internal channels
Parts customization and personalization Porosity in material necessitating hot isostatic pressing

Differences Between Metal Injection Molding and Additive Manufacturing for Titanium Parts

Parameter Metal Injection Molding Additive Manufacturing
Process Mixing fine metal powder with binders, injection molding, followed by debinding and sintering Layerwise fusion of titanium powder to build parts directly using lasers or electron beam
Part complexity Only simple 2.5 D geometries possible Highly complex shapes like lattices can be printed
Part size Up to several inches Limited by build volume, typically under 20 inches
Accuracy Very high, down to ±0.5% with easy tolerances Moderate, around ±0.2% on dimensions
Surface finish Excellent due to molding process Poorer surface requiring additional post-processing
Mechanical properties Isotropic, less residual stresses Anisotropic properties, higher residual stresses
Material options Limited alloys and blends Wide range of titanium grades and customized alloys
Setup costs High initial tooling investment Lower startup costs
Production quantities High volumes, up to millions of units Optimized for small batches of 10-10,000 units
Lead time Longer lead time for tooling manufacture Shorter time to functional part, rapid design iterations

Comparison Between Selective Laser Melting (SLM) and Electron Beam Melting (EBM) for Titanium AM

Parameter Selective Laser Melting (SLM) Electron Beam Melting (EBM)
Heat source Focused laser beam High-power electron beam
Atmosphere Inert argon gas Vacuum
Thermal input Highly localized input from laser Broader input from large electron beam
Accuracy Higher due to finer laser spot size Lower by 10-100 μm
Surface finish Smoother surface, easier to polish Grainier, porous surface finish
Build speed Slower, approx. 5-20 cm3/hr Faster, upto 45 cm3/hr
Alloys used Ti-6Al-4V, commercially pure Ti, others Mainly Ti-6Al-4V
Cost Higher equipment and operating costs Lower cost of ownership
Porosity Lower porosity, around 0.5% Higher porosity around 5%
Microstructure Fine prior beta grains with alpha laths Coarser beta grains and acicular alpha’ martensite
Post-processing Lower heat treatment needs HIP often required to reduce porosity
Mechanical properties Higher strength and ductility Lower strength with higher anisotropy
Applications Aerospace, medical implants, automotive Aerospace, biomedical

In summary, SLM offers better accuracy and surface finish while EBM has the advantage of faster build speeds. The layerwise melting process induces residual stresses and anisotropic material properties in both methods.

AlSi12 Powder
PREPed Metal Powders

FAQ

Q. Which titanium alloys are commonly used in additive manufacturing?

A. Ti-6Al-4V is the most widely used titanium alloy, making up over 50% of titanium AM. Other alloys include Ti-6Al-4V ELI, commercially pure grades 2 and 4 titanium, Ti-6Al-7Nb, and Ti-5Al-5Mo-5V-3Cr.

Q. What types of post-processing are typically needed for additively manufactured titanium parts?

A. Post-processing steps like hot isostatic pressing (HIP), heat treatment, surface machining, drilling, polishing and application of coatings are usually required to achieve desired dimensional accuracy, surface finish, and material properties.

Q. How do the mechanical properties of additively manufactured titanium compare to wrought and cast titanium?

A. AM titanium parts can match or exceed the tensile strength and fatigue strength of wrought and cast titanium. However, AM titanium exhibits anisotropy in properties due to the layered manufacturing unlike traditional methods.

Q. What are some methods used to improve fatigue performance of additively manufactured titanium?

A. Fatigue performance can be improved by applying hot isostatic pressing (HIP), shot peening, chemical etching, machining, and other post-processing steps to induce compressive stresses, remove surface defects, and improve microstructure.

Q. Does additive manufacturing reduce costs for titanium parts compared to traditional methods?

A. For small batch sizes, AM offers significant cost reduction compared to machining from billet. For mass production, the high cost of powder material means AM is still more expensive than casting or forging.

Q. How does the surface roughness of AM titanium compare to CNC machining?

A. As-printed titanium components have a higher surface roughness of 10-25 μm Ra compared to machined surfaces which can achieve under 1 μm Ra. Additional post-processing is required if a smoother surface finish is needed.

Q. What safety precautions are required when handling titanium powder?

A. Titanium powder should be stored in an inert environment to prevent oxidation. Handling procedures must prevent dust formation and inhalation. Powder compartments in machines need inert gas purging and O2 monitoring.

Q. What are some advantages of using AM to manufacture titanium components instead of steel?

A. AM titanium provides a superior strength-to-weight ratio compared to steel. It also offers better corrosion resistance, bio-compatibility, and high temperature performance making it suitable for aerospace, medical, and automotive uses.

Q. How does build orientation affect properties and quality of AM titanium parts?

A. Build orientation can significantly affect residual stresses, surface finish, geometric accuracy and mechanical properties like strength and ductility. Parts are often oriented to minimize support structures.

Q. What are some key considerations when designing parts for additive manufacturing from titanium?

A. Key design considerations include minimizing overhangs, incorporating build supports, maintaining wall thicknesses between 0.8-4 mm, allowing access holes for unfused powder removal, and accounting for post-processing requirements.

Conclusion

Additive manufacturing makes the production of complex titanium components viable and economical compared to conventional methods. With advancing technology and greater adoption, titanium AM enables lighter, stronger, and more capable designs across crucial industries. However, process challenges like residual stresses, anisotropy, surface finish, and standards continue to be addressed through research and development. With further maturation, AM has the potential to realize the full capabilities of titanium metal and transform manufacturing worldwide.

know more 3D printing processes

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

More To Explore

Titanium Additive Manufacturing

Overview of Titanium Additive Manufacturing Titanium additive manufacturing, also known as 3D printing of titanium, refers to various additive manufacturing techniques used to fabricate titanium components in a layer-by-layer manner directly from 3D model data. It allows for the creation of complex titanium parts with high geometrical freedom that are either impossible or very costly

3D Printer Metal Powders

3D printer metal powders are specialty metallic powders used as raw materials in various metal 3D printing processes. These powders allow complex metal parts and components to be fabricated layer-by-layer using additive manufacturing techniques. Overview of 3D Printer Metal Powders 3D printer metal powders exhibit specific characteristics that make them suitable for additive manufacturing compared

en_GBEnglish
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top